Three Stories. The photographers seeking to give visibility to the inhabitants and to the complexity and nuances of African culture; such is the topic of the exhibition. These young authors do not wish to exercise judgement upon the situations unfolding before their camera lenses, but by revealing marginal events, to convey a sense of the values, conditions, objects and incidents of everyday life, while keeping a political eye on the changing world around them.
Curators: Marguy Conzémius, Michèle Walerich
Three stories about Africa, presented by two African photographers of the post-Apartheid generation and a
Dutch-Canadian photographer, seeking to give visibility to the inhabitants and to the complexity
and nuances of African culture; such is the topic of the present exhibition. These young authors do
not wish to exercise judgement upon the situations unfolding before their camera lenses, but
instead, by revealing marginal events, to convey a sense of the values, conditions, objects and
incidents of everyday life, while keeping a political eye on the changing world around them.
Wishing to keep their distance from traditional photojournalism, setting little store by the rules of
the mass media and refusing to apply the clichés with which the image of Africa has been imbued
since the colonial period and the era of Apartheid, they are inspired of the photographic approach
of artists like David Goldblatt, Roger Ballen and Guy Tillim.
Rather than scouring the continent camera in hand, seizing the moment, as it were, they forge
personal relationships with their models, working over long periods of time, focusing on calm and
"secondary" situations, switching between documentary and artistic photography while having
recourse to portrait and a degree of mise en scène.
Besides these common characteristics, it is important to underline certain particularities of these
three photographic undertakings.
Pieter Hugo uses the contrasts and oppositions that arise between the urban and the wild,
affection and brutality, beauty and atrocity, to create a dramaturgy stemming from the protagonists
themselves and not from their actions. Via this approach he eliminates the notion of the
spectacular and manages to give importance to the non-visible to reveal another – a new – image
of Africa, not that of a country ravaged by war or famine, nor that of wonderful "safariesque" ,
settings.
Mikhael Subotzky plays with colours and luminosity (the city shots are often dark and somewhat
drab, while those of the prison are shot in vivid colours and with greater luminosity). Hence his
discourse reveals surprising twists... For example, life behind bars seems – contrary to what one
might expect – better than that of the underprivileged inhabitants of Beaufort West. Via such
surprising and unexpected moments, he manages to bring to the surface people and situations of
which the mass media does not speak.
Paolo Woods, the only one of the three photographers who is not of African origin, opposes two
cultures: that of the Chinese workers and investors who come to Africa to live out their "American
Dream" and that of the Africans who hope for a better life through this new form of colonisation.
He makes portraits – often staged to a degree, icon like, imbued with a striking symbolism – and
opposes these pictures with photographs of a more documentary nature. The portraits highlight
African/Chinese cohabitation and its consequences, a phenomenon that the mass media overlooks
when talking about the subject.
The dissemination of these three stories takes place at various levels. Pieter Hugo and Mikhael
Subotzky, represented by a gallery and a photographic agency, have their work presented in
museums, galleries, festivals of renown or in art publications. Paolo Woods, who has teamed up
with a journalist in order to carry out his work has chosen to publish his work in magazines and
journalistic investigations. As a result, he accepts that his photos take on the status of illustration.
Yet via this means of distribution he manages to access a very large public which does not hail
simply from the worlds of photography or art, thus enabling him to extricate the subject from its
tendency to marginalization on a much larger scale.
The stylistic and thematic approaches which have led to this collection of "stories" overlap on
several occasions, yet each photographer – by bringing to bear his own personal vision, experience
and commitment – has created his own universe and his own discourse. By leaving shocking
imagery behind them – which in any case no longer has any impact due to overexposure – they
seek instead, in order to pass on a message, to adopt a new photographic language via which they
surprise the viewer, inciting us to observe more wisely, to ask why and to call ourselves into
question.
Marguy Conzémius
The Hyena and Other men is the story of men, who in the company of hyenas, pythons and
baboons, earn their living doing street performances for the crowd and selling traditional medicine.
Captivated by a picture he came across in a South-African news paper depicting men with their
hyenas in the streets of Lagos and Nigeria, Pieter Hugo decided to go and meet them. A few weeks
later, accompanied by a local reporter, they hooked up with them in shanty town on the outskirts of
Abuja, to take to the road with this troupe and to get to know their fascinating world a little better.
Bit by bit, he got to meet the animal merchants, with their traditional rites and strove to photograph
their daily round. He quickly realized that what really interested him in this subject was the hybrid
crossover of the urban and the wild and the paradoxical, often very affectionate, at other times
cruel and brutal, relationship that the merchants have with their animals.
Via a series of extraordinary portraits of this marginal existence taken over the space of two years
(2005 to 2007), we discover a world characterized by complex relationships and interdependencies,
a world which wavers between traditions, myths and modernity, domination and submission.
Beaufort West is a small town in the middle of the desert, intersected by the national N1 highway,
lying halfway between Cape Town and Johannesburg, and crossed every year by millions of cars.
Here, as in most South African rural towns, agricultural activity has fallen off considerably from one
generation to the next, causing an exodus to the big cities. Beaufort West is a desolate place.
Unemployment is rife and it has a very high crime rate. Those who remain, or who return here, have
been rejected everywhere else. Yet as one leaves the town centre one happens upon an amazing
sight: a prison, standing in the middle of a roundabout.
Mikhael Subotzky, having already carried out several photographic projects in South African
prisons, decided to spend time in Beaufort West to sketch a portrait of the town. Between 2006
and 2008, he would return there regularly, to live with the people, going out to meet them in the
company of Major, a very popular guy about town. He took a particular interest in problems of
marginalization, incarceration and disillusion to create an inventory of the social reality of South
Africa in the post-Apartheid world.
Paolo Woods - Chinafrica
In 2007, Paolo Woods set out to recount the adventure of the conquest of the African continent by
the Chinese. In search of coveted raw materials – copper, uranium and timber – Beijing has sent
forth its most adventurous companies and entrepreneurs.
500.000 Chinese emigrants to Africa are striving to make their fortune, in a continent which the
West only deemed worthy of receiving humanitarian aide. Some are managing large
conglomerates, while others are selling bargain items along the roadsides of some of the world's
poorest countries. Accompanied by the journalist Serge Michel, Paolo Woods travelled across 15
countries, criss-crossing the entire continent to encounter these two very different worlds, from the
threatened forests of the Congo to the karaoke bars of Nigeria, along the pipelines of Sudan and
the railroads of Angola, from the top ministries in the capitals to the devastated countryside.
Chinafrica also tells us of a bygone era. The Chinese have little in common with the former
colonisers – they build roads, hospitals and schools. For the Africans, it's a new phenomenon
which makes no claims of democracy or transparency, a law beyond dictatorial regimes. The
images in Chinafrica are a rare and surprising portrait of an unsuspected here and now, as well as
a condensed portrait of a globalized world.
Image: Paolo Woods, Chinafrique, Nigeria, Lagos, 2007 // Nigeria, Lagos, 2007
Production: Département Photographie / CNA
CNA gratefully acknowledges Michael Stevenson, Cape Town, and Yossi Milo,
New York / Magnum Photos, Foam and KLM Paul Huf Award / Paolo Woods
Catalogue
Publisher: Centre national de l’audiovisuel (CNA) / Dudelange
Texts, interviews, editorial direction : Marguy Conzémius, Michèle Walerich (CNA)
Translation: Peter Leonard (english), Yusuf Samantar (french)
Communication:
Jean-Marie Spartz, Responsable du service
Tél : 52 2424-224 E-mail: jean-marie.spartz@cna.etat.lu
Opening: Saturday 28th March 2009, 2:30pm
with special event FOTOMATON - a project by BOZAR and OST
Centre national de l’audiovisuel (CNA) - DISPLAY01
1b rue du Centenaire L-3475 Dudelange
Tuesday - Sunday : 10 am -10 pm.
Guided tours upon request